In 1988, Barry Bonds, then a rising star with the Pittsburgh Pirates, married Sun in Las Vegas. The couple signed a prenuptial agreement the day before the wedding. Sun, who had emigrated from Sweden and for whom English was a second language, signed without independent legal counsel.
When the couple divorced in 1994 (Bonds was by then earning approximately $8 million per year with the San Francisco Giants), Sun challenged the prenup as involuntary. She argued that the circumstances surrounding signing, the timing, the lack of independent counsel, and the language barrier, rendered her agreement involuntary.
The California Supreme Court ultimately upheld the agreement in 2000, establishing what became known as the "totality of circumstances" test for voluntariness. The court considered that lack of independent counsel isone factor among many, not an automatic ground for invalidation. The court weighed Sun's sophistication, whether she was given an opportunity to consult an attorney, and whether she appeared to understand the agreement's terms.